Follow us on Google Get our news on Discover Follow

A 170-foot concrete tower in a California reservoir has had 40 feet cut off its top, ring by concrete ring from a crane on a floating barge, because the dam beside it was built 33 feet lower than planned and left the tower that is the lake’s only safe drain too tall for an earthquake

A 170-foot concrete tower in a California reservoir has had 40 feet cut off its top, ring by concrete ring from a crane on a floating barge, because the dam beside it was built 33 feet lower than planned and left the tower that is the lake’s only safe drain too tall for an earthquake

{{author_name}}

Luis Reyes

Nov 17, at 2:00pm ET

Measure twice, cut once.

Repeat it with me: Measure twice, cut once.

It’s pretty good advice whether you’re working on a project car or a water tower. But it can’t do much when the thing you measured against shrinks after your part’s already been poured in concrete.

That’s basically what happened to Lafayette Reservoir’s outlet tower. The lake sits in Lafayette, California, a suburb east of Oakland, and the East Bay Municipal Utility District, or EBMUD, owns and operates it. The tower went up in 1929, built for a taller dam than today’s. According to a 2023 presentation EBMUD gave the Lafayette City Council, the original dam failed during construction, and the dam that eventually got finished came in 33 feet lower than planned. That left a 170-foot concrete tower standing in the water 40 feet taller than it needed to be.

If you’re wondering how a dam that’s 33 feet short leaves a tower 40 feet too tall, you’re not alone. EBMUD’s project page and that presentation give both numbers, and I couldn’t find a line in either that explains the 7-foot gap.

It took the better part of a century, but this summer EBMUD finally cut the tower down. And it did it without draining the lake, which meant floating a crane out to the tower on a barge and lifting the top off one concrete ring at a time.

The tower is the reservoir’s drain

At this point, you can probably tell the tower isn’t there for looks.

It’s the reservoir’s outlet and its spillway at the same time. A spillway is basically the overflow drain on your bathtub. When the water gets high enough, it goes down the tower and out through a big pipe under the dam, rather than finding its own way over the top. EBMUD says California’s Division of Safety of Dams (DSOD) treats the tower as a critical structure for exactly that reason, and that it’s “the only safe method to drain water from the reservoir.”

So what’s wrong with a little extra height?

Picture holding a broom upright by the end of the handle and giving it a shake. The longer the handle and the heavier the head, the harder the whole thing yanks at your wrist, and that’s pretty much what an earthquake does to a tall tower: more weight up high, more strain at the base. EBMUD’s seismic studies say the Lafayette tower could bend and break in a major earthquake. The 2023 presentation adds that a damaged tower likely couldn’t work as a spillway or an outlet anymore.

Which means the worry is losing the structure EBMUD relies on to control the water level, right when you’d most want it working. DSOD rates the risk downstream of the dam as extremely high, and EBMUD says a failure could send uncontrolled water toward Lafayette and Walnut Creek.

There’s a reason to take that seriously here. The Moraga Fault runs right under the reservoir, and EBMUD says its last major quake hit in 1956, at magnitude 5.2. It’s part of the larger Hayward Fault System, which EBMUD says can produce a magnitude 7.25 in the region. The tower was already standing for the 1956 quake, at 27 years old. It’s nearly 100 now, and EBMUD’s Christopher Tritto told CBS San Francisco that age and deterioration make a taller tower more likely to crack. I’d say that’s a pretty fair argument for not waiting around for the next big one.

So how do you shorten a tower in the middle of a lake?

The obvious move would be to drain the reservoir and work from the bottom. EBMUD said early on it wouldn’t need to, and its 2023 presentation lists lowering the reservoir as not required. The state had already capped how high EBMUD could fill it. So the crane came by water.

CBS reported that crews got going on Friday, July 10, with a crane parked on a floating barge pulling pieces off the top. The old operating house went first, the little building that’s sat on top of the tower for close to a century. Then came the stem itself. According to Bay Area Telegraph’s reading of EBMUD’s monthly status reports, crews cut it away as 13 concrete rings. Picture a really tall stack of concrete donuts being unstacked from a boat, one donut at a time. Frankly, I think the barge is the cleverest part of the whole job, since the lake doubles as a popular park and draining it would’ve been a much bigger mess.

EBMUD’s fourth monthly report said 10 of the 13 rings were gone by August 17. The last three were due out by Friday, August 21, and when Bay Area Telegraph went to look that day, the tower appeared to be at its new height. EBMUD’s November update to local stakeholders, which the Lafayette Chamber of Commerce republished, confirms it. EBMUD says the operating house came off this summer and the tower lost about 40 feet.

Good info so far, but EBMUD hasn’t published a new official height. You can do the subtraction yourself (170 minus 40 is 130 feet), but that’s my arithmetic (and I’m not a math nerd), not a number from the utility, and EBMUD’s own wording on the cut is approximate.

Original height
170 ft
Concrete outlet and spillway tower, 8 ft inside diameter, built in 1929.
Source: EBMUD presentation, Jan. 9, 2023; EBMUD
Cut off the top
40 ft
Removed in 13 concrete rings from a crane on a floating barge.
Source: EBMUD; Bay Area Telegraph
Dam shortfall
33 ft
How much lower the dam was built than planned, after the original failed during construction.
Source: EBMUD presentation, Jan. 9, 2023
Project cost
$14 million
Paid for by EBMUD ratepayers and approved by DSOD.
Source: EBMUD

The tower isn’t finished yet

If you walk the loop around the reservoir, you’ve probably noticed the tower looks a bit bald right now. That’s temporary. EBMUD’s project page says the new top will be a metal operating house designed to look a lot like the old one, and the district’s customer newsletter described it back in March as lighter and more modern, but inspired by the original. Going lighter seems pretty sensible on a tower you’ve just spent a summer making less top-heavy.

It’s also a nice nod to locals who weren’t thrilled about losing a landmark, and at least one visitor CBS talked to on day one said it was kind of sad to watch it change.

EBMUD’s November update says crews are framing that house now and expect it done by the end of November. After that, tower work stops for the season once the year’s environmental work window shuts. Crews are due back in May 2027 to put in new slide gates underwater, plus the electric motors that open and close them, then finish the wiring, testing, and commissioning. Work on the outlet pipe under the dam carries on through the winter, and DSOD has also required an onshore valve system so EBMUD can respond faster in an emergency.

If you caught our piece on the 135-foot outlet tower in Orange County’s Irvine Lake, you’ll know these old towers can run into very different problems. That one has its lowest gates buried in silt. Lafayette’s trouble sat at the other end of the tower.

The whole job comes to $14 million, which EBMUD says its ratepayers are covering, so if you get a water bill from the district, you’re chipping in. DSOD has signed off on the plan.

EBMUD expects crews back on the Lafayette tower in May 2027, and it still has the full project down for completion in fall 2027.

THE LOTvia The Lot

Agree or laugh out loud?

Sign in with Google when you post
ROOKIE›DRIVER›ENTHUSIAST›EXPERT›LEGEND ★
THE LOTOwner community
Visit →
Luis Reyes

Luis Reyes

With more than 14 years covering the automotive industry, Luis Reyes is a seasoned voice in the field. A law graduate, he channels his curiosity and expertise into the detailed analysis of national and international regulations that shape the automotive world. At Autonocion.com, Luis combines his strong legal background with a deep passion for vehicles — especially those that have left a mark on automotive history. His experience writing for multiple brands across the industry has established him as a trusted authority. Luis is committed to sharing his expertise and enthusiasm with enthusiasts and industry professionals alike, with a firm belief in the continuous evolution and innovation driving the auto industry forward.
Contact: info@autonocion.com