Follow us on Google Get our news on Discover Follow

An American seabed drone went more than 13,000 feet down in the Pacific, deeper than the Titanic, and picked potato-sized metal nodules off the seafloor one at a time, skipping any with life on them, then floated about a pound back up with no pipe to its ship

An American seabed drone went more than 13,000 feet down in the Pacific, deeper than the Titanic, and picked potato-sized metal nodules off the seafloor one at a time, skipping any with life on them, then floated about a pound back up with no pipe to its ship

{{author_name}}

Luis Reyes

Nov 16, at 3:30pm ET

You probably know the Titanic is a long way down. The wreck sits about 12,500 feet below the North Atlantic, which goes a long way toward explaining why it took explorers more than seven decades to find it. So when a company wants you to understand how deep its robot went, the Titanic is a pretty handy yardstick.

Impossible Metals reached for exactly that comparison on November 9. In its announcement, the company says its Eureka robot went more than 2.5 miles down to the floor of the Pacific, deeper than the Titanic, and collected seabed nodules on its own, choosing them one at a time before bringing them back to the surface. Reuters reports the dive itself took place during a scientific expedition in September, and the company only went public with it now.

If the name sounds familiar, that’s because we’ve covered Eureka twice already. In July we looked at the 16-arm production robot Impossible Metals wants to build, and in September we wrote about Eureka II finding its own ship off Halifax and getting hauled aboard with nobody at the controls. This dive is the one the company is calling proof that the whole concept works.

So what’s a nodule, anyway?

Polymetallic nodules are lumps of rock, usually around the size of a potato, that sit loose on the abyssal plain. That’s the flat, muddy floor of the deep ocean, miles below the surface. The nodules grow incredibly slowly over millions of years, and they’re loaded with nickel, cobalt, copper and manganese, which is why battery makers and governments keep eyeing them.

The Clarion-Clipperton Zone, where Eureka made this dive, is a huge stretch of Pacific seabed between Hawaii and Mexico that’s covered in them. Most companies that want those nodules plan to collect them with what’s basically a giant vacuum cleaner on tracks. It crawls across the bottom sucking up rocks and sediment, and a riser pipe that’s miles long pumps the whole mix up to a ship.

That approach has already been trialed. A Belgian company ran a tractor-style collector called Patania II through this same zone a few years ago. Environmental groups really don’t like the vacuum idea, though, and it isn’t hard to see why. You’re scraping up the top layer of seabed along with whatever happens to be living on it.

Eureka hovers instead of driving

Impossible Metals went a different way. Eureka stays off the bottom entirely, hovering over the seabed instead of landing and rolling across it. It checks out what’s underneath with cameras and software, and uses robotic arms to pick up individual nodules. If a nodule has visible life on it or right next to it, the company says Eureka leaves it alone.

So how do the rocks get back to the surface without a pipe?

Basically, the robot plays with its own buoyancy. When it weighs more than the water it displaces, it sinks, and when it weighs less, it floats. It’s roughly the same trick a submarine pulls with its ballast tanks, just on a much smaller machine. Impossible Metals calls the system that handles this a buoyancy engine, and the company says it means you don’t need a riser pipe at all. You also skip the water that riser systems pump up along with the rocks and then have to discharge back into the sea.

It’s a pretty elegant idea, and frankly a lot easier to picture than a pipe several miles long hanging off a ship. Whether it scales is a different question, and we’ll come back to that.

Impossible Metals says this makes Eureka the first fully autonomous underwater robot to selectively collect polymetallic nodules from the deep ocean. That’s a pretty specific claim, and the details matter. Nodules have been hauled up from the deep plenty of times before, by dredges, sleds and collector trials like the Belgian one. What the company is claiming is a robot that picked its own rocks, hovered instead of driving, and didn’t need a pipe to get them home.

About a pound of rocks for a bacteria lab

How much did Eureka actually bring back? About a pound. That won’t keep any battery factory busy, and to be fair, Impossible Metals isn’t claiming it should.

The company says the dive was run as marine scientific research and that the amount it collected reflects that. The nodules are headed to Viridian Biometals, a research partner working on bacterial methods for recovering metals from nodules. Viridian plans to study the bacteria populations that live inside the rocks.

I’ll admit there’s something a little funny about sending a robot deeper than the Titanic and coming home with a lab sample. But if you’re trying to show a concept works without anyone accusing you of quietly opening a mine, a pound of rocks for microbiologists is probably the smart amount to grab.

Dive depth
13,100+ ft
More than 2.5 miles down in the Clarion-Clipperton Zone. The Titanic wreck sits at about 12,500 feet.
Nodules collected
About 1 lb
Picked one at a time for Viridian Biometals’ bacteria research. No riser pipe.
Independent scientists
9
A standing group working with the company. Dive data is due to be published openly.
TARGET
Next test
2027
Eureka III, the scaled-up version, in front of independent scientists aboard RV SONNE.

Impossible Metals also says it’ll publish all the scientific data from the dive, the same way it did with the Eureka II dives on the Blake Plateau, off the US Southeast coast, a couple of years ago. It works with a standing group of nine independent scientists, too, and says they’re allowed to criticize the company publicly if they want to.

Who’s paying for this?

The announcement names two backers. One is In-Q-Tel, or IQT, which Impossible Metals describes as the strategic investor for America’s intelligence and national security community. The other is the Smith family of FedEx.

Richard Smith, who’s CEO of FedEx Airline and COO of FedEx International, says in the release that his father cared about the US locking down a supply of nodules for its industry and its national security. Reuters adds that the company has backing from startup accelerator Y Combinator as well.

So yes, a seabed robot now has an intelligence-community investor in its corner. I wouldn’t read too much into that, though. The dive was a science mission, and the release pitches Eureka purely as a way to collect nodules.

Steve Curnutte, Impossible Metals’ executive chairman and CEO, sounds pretty confident about where things stand. “Eureka is proven, patented, and ready,” he says in the release, adding that the job now is manufacturing and scaling up, with the inventing already done. The patent is US patent 12,704,065, granted on August 11, 2026, and it lists company co-founders Oliver Gunasekara and Jason Gillham as the inventors.

“Proven” is a big word for one dive and a pound of rocks, if you ask me. Still, the business plan makes sense on its own terms. Impossible Metals wants to offer Eureka as robots-as-a-service, working with contractors that hold licenses to nodule areas. Curnutte’s argument is that you expand the operation one robot at a time, without sinking money into massive infrastructure on day one.

Eureka III gets the bigger test

The next test is the one I’d actually keep an eye on. Impossible Metals says Eureka III, the scaled-up version, will run in 2027 in front of an independent scientific team aboard RV SONNE, a German research vessel. It’s part of an environmental impact study started by BGR, Germany’s Federal Institute for Geosciences and Natural Resources.

That trial has already slipped once. When we wrote about Eureka III in July, the company had pushed it back from an earlier target, so I’d treat 2027 as the current plan rather than a promise.

Eureka still can’t mine anything

The catch is that none of this gives Impossible Metals permission to start mining. According to Reuters, the company still needs approval from either the International Seabed Authority or the US government.

If you haven’t heard of the ISA, it’s the organization set up under the UN’s Law of the Sea treaty to oversee mining in international waters, which cover most of the Clarion-Clipperton Zone. It hands out exploration contracts, but it hasn’t approved commercial mining there for anyone yet. The US never ratified that treaty, which is why a US government route even comes up.

So what don’t we know?

Quite a bit, actually. Impossible Metals hasn’t given an exact depth beyond saying it was more than 2.5 miles, a date for the dive, or how long Eureka spent on the bottom. It also hasn’t said how many nodules the robot looked at and decided to skip. That’s the number I’d most like to see, since the whole pitch rests on Eureka leaving the living stuff alone.

Then there’s the robot itself. The photos and video Impossible Metals offered with the announcement are of Eureka II, but the release doesn’t say that’s the vehicle that made this dive, so I can’t tell you how big or heavy the machine down there was. The company hasn’t shared how much it raised from In-Q-Tel or the Smiths, either.

What we do know is when the next proper look comes. Impossible Metals says Eureka III will be tested aboard RV SONNE in 2027 with independent scientists watching, and that’s when we’ll find out how the hovering approach holds up at a bigger scale.

THE LOTvia The Lot

Agree or laugh out loud?

Sign in with Google when you post
ROOKIE›DRIVER›ENTHUSIAST›EXPERT›LEGEND ★
THE LOTOwner community
Visit →
Luis Reyes

Luis Reyes

With more than 14 years covering the automotive industry, Luis Reyes is a seasoned voice in the field. A law graduate, he channels his curiosity and expertise into the detailed analysis of national and international regulations that shape the automotive world. At Autonocion.com, Luis combines his strong legal background with a deep passion for vehicles — especially those that have left a mark on automotive history. His experience writing for multiple brands across the industry has established him as a trusted authority. Luis is committed to sharing his expertise and enthusiasm with enthusiasts and industry professionals alike, with a firm belief in the continuous evolution and innovation driving the auto industry forward.
Contact: info@autonocion.com
New 3D film · Watch on YouTubeThe First Hour of a War Could Ground Every US Fighter. Except The X-BAT