Follow us on Google Get our news on Discover Follow

A 1,526-ton World War II submarine with no propellers was towed 113 miles back across Lake Michigan in 15 hours by two tugboats and eased into her museum berth by 10 a.m., after a Wisconsin shipyard found only 10% of her hull steel had worn away in her first dry dock in 72 years

A 1,526-ton World War II submarine with no propellers was towed 113 miles back across Lake Michigan in 15 hours by two tugboats and eased into her museum berth by 10 a.m., after a Wisconsin shipyard found only 10% of her hull steel had worn away in her first dry dock in 72 years

{{author_name}}

Chema Bonilla Díaz

Nov 18, at 12:49pm ET

Pull a boat out of Lake Michigan after a season and you’ll probably find zebra mussels glued to the bottom. Leave it in the water a few years too long and you start to wonder what the steel looks like under them.

USS Silversides didn’t come out of the water for 72 years. The World War II submarine’s last dry dock visit was in 1954, according to MLive, and she’s been a museum ship in Muskegon, Michigan, since 1987. So when a Wisconsin shipyard finally lifted her out this summer, I think a lot of people were expecting a long list of bad news.

It didn’t really go that way. And since Nov. 7, you’ve been able to walk through her again.

She came home on Halloween morning

MLive says Silversides pulled away from Fincantieri Bay Shipbuilding at about 4:30 p.m. Wisconsin time on Friday, Oct. 30. She was in the Muskegon Channel by 8:30 a.m. Saturday.

If you just subtract one clock time from the other, you get 16 hours. But Wisconsin runs an hour behind Michigan, so the tow really took 15, which is the number MLive went with.

Two tugboats did all the work. The tugs Nickelena and Erika Kobasic are both longer than 100 feet and belong to Basic Towing out of Escanaba, Michigan. They’re the same pair that dragged her 113 miles to Wisconsin on July 13 and 14, a trip that took 16 hours. This time, they turned her inside Muskegon Lake and had her back at the museum’s dock before 10 a.m., while a little flotilla of local boats tagged along.

So why does a submarine need two tugboats in the first place?

Because Silversides hasn’t had propellers since 1947, when they were removed, according to MLive. By the Navy’s count she has a surface displacement of 1,526 tons, and without propellers all that steel is basically a barge that happens to be shaped like a submarine. One tug pulls, the other pushes, and the sub just goes along for the ride.

That’s also why the Coast Guard wanted to see some homework before it let her go. She had to clear five benchmarks, among them a float test and an incline test that checks her stability, plus ballasting, a few last touch-ups and getting the tow gear ready. MLive reported she cleared all five the week of the crossing. As far as I can tell, the Coast Guard hasn’t released the numbers behind any of those tests, so the only thing on record is a pass.

How much of her hull was actually left?

This is where the news got good. The shipyard’s inspection put her hull steel wastage at only about 10%, and museum executive director Veronica Campbell called that “incredible for a vessel of her age” in an interview with MLive.

If you’ve never run into the word, wastage is the yard’s term for metal a hull has lost to corrosion for good. It’s usually measured against a plate’s original thickness, so a 10% figure means the hull has given up something like a tenth of its metal since it was built. The museum hasn’t published plate-by-plate readings, so I can’t tell you where her thinnest spots turned out to be.

Campbell credits that mostly to fresh water, and that tracks. Corrosion is chemistry with a bit of electricity mixed in, since steel gives up electrons and the surrounding water has to carry that current for the reaction to keep going. Ocean water carries it easily because of all the dissolved salt. Lake water doesn’t, so in a freshwater channel the whole process slows way down.

That doesn’t mean the yard had an easy summer. Vessel curator Scott Hardin told MLive that plenty of fresh steel got welded to her underside, and workers also welded over flood valves down there to strengthen the openings that lead into her ballast tanks.

Those tanks were their own little adventure. Nobody had opened them in 72 years, and Campbell said they were full of silt, assorted debris and worms. Once they were cleaned out, though, the tanks looked healthy enough that the museum could skip some of the coatings it had lined up for them.

Then there are the time capsules. Workers found a pair of propeller nuts still threaded onto her shafts, and they came off easily, according to MLive. The museum plans to put them on display. The strangest find of the summer, a flood valve stamped for her sister sub, already got its own story when we covered what turned up in the Wisconsin dry dock.

She also left with a fresh coat of paint. MLive says she’s black below and two-tone gray up top again, the way she looked in 1945.

So why not stop early?

The museum’s new 20-to-30-year estimate came out of a choice Campbell described to MLive. Costs climbed partway through the job, so the museum could either stop there and buy itself eight to 10 years of breathing room, or finish everything and push her next dry dock out 20 to 30 years. It chose to finish, since Campbell said coming back later would’ve roughly doubled the bill.

I’d have made the same choice, frankly. Each round trip means two tugs, a Coast Guard inspection and a slot at a Great Lakes shipyard, and I doubt any of that gets cheaper.

The whole project ran $3.5 million, helped along by a $750,000 Save America’s Treasures grant from the National Park Service. WLUK in Green Bay reported on Oct. 30 that the museum was still about $215,000 away from its fundraising goal, and I haven’t been able to find an updated figure since. Any money that comes in past the $3.5 million mark will be set aside in an endowment for her next dry dock, according to MLive.

Return tow
15 hours / 113 miles
Sturgeon Bay, Wis., to Muskegon, Oct. 30 to 31. July’s trip out: 16 hours, 113 miles.
Source: MLive
Hull steel wastage
About 10%
What the Wisconsin shipyard found in her steel hull.
Source: Veronica Campbell via MLive
Between dry docks
72 years
Her previous dry dock visit was in 1954.
Source: MLive
ACTIVE
Tours reopened
Nov. 7
Winter hours: Thursday to Monday, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.
Sources: WOOD TV8, USS Silversides Submarine Museum

Moving a museum ship isn’t always this straightforward, by the way. When we wrote about the USS Kidd, the destroyer could only float back into her riverbank cradle once the Mississippi reached 32 feet in Baton Rouge. Silversides just had to wait on a Coast Guard OK and a couple of tugs. And over on the Wisconsin side of the lake, her sister sub USS Cobia spent six weeks in dry dock last year at the Wisconsin Maritime Museum in Manitowoc, according to WLUK.

You can go aboard again

The museum kept the sub closed for a week after the tow so crews could deep-clean her interior, and WOOD TV8 reported visitors were stepping back inside on Saturday, Nov. 7.

Just check the calendar before you drive out. The museum switched to winter hours on Nov. 1, so it’s open Thursday through Monday and closed on Tuesdays and Wednesdays, with doors open from 10 a.m. until 4 p.m. Ticket sales stop 30 minutes before closing, and adult admission is $18, according to the museum’s visit page. That winter schedule runs through March 31.

THE LOTvia The Lot
4 comments

What do you think?

Sign in with Google when you post
ROOKIE›DRIVER›ENTHUSIAST›EXPERT›LEGEND ★
@harryjohn ROOKIE2 weeks ago
I think we already and have been overpaying for are navy. I mean come on everyone knows aircraft and drones are future and with so many on a aircraft it would be terrible 1 of those hydroponic missiles could take all of out. Our airforce can handle the air themselves and our future naval power aint as important as it was in the 1900s 2000s and coast and delivery rate is unreal. Nobody even buys are old boats like most did before. And if you look at including the older branch the coast guard has about the 3rd biggest navy. We have so much that are extremely old or obsolete that we could submerge Australia and untied kingdom. Then he pay more for even more newer boats that take years to build. The budget should be put in the sailors more and there bases the last thing the USA needs is more boats
0
@lawrenceromanow ROOKIE2 weeks ago
Reminds me of movie called Down Periscope by Kelsey Kramer. Ironic isn’t it. ?
0
@billscheitzach ROOKIE2 weeks ago
A sister ship, the USS Cobia (SS-245), is moored across the lake at the Wisconsin Maritime Museum in Manitowoc as a museum ship.
0
@kevinclegg ROOKIE2 weeks ago
It was heartwarming to read the story of the Silversides' return and berthing. Although I was unaware that it was going into dry dock for maintenance, reading about its return to duty brought back wonderful memories. The museum not only shares the story of the Silversides and its crew, but also provides a learning experience. Twenty years ago I was fortunate enough to be one of a handful of Cub Scout leaders who did a "tour of duty" on the Silversides with our pack of young men. It was winter time and we slept overnight in the berths after having dinner in the mess hall. There was a lingering odor of machine oil and electric heaters, because submarines were notoriously chilly. I also remember how the adults all took our time at "watch" to monitor any issues overnight. One unique memory is that a few of the cub scouts remarked about the soft banging on the hull during the night. In the morning, we discovered it was from large pieces of ice that had floated into the channel from Lake Michigan.
Thank you for reminding me of a wonderful event.
0
THE LOTOwner community
Visit →
Chema Bonilla Díaz

Chema Bonilla Díaz

Chema Bonilla covers the auto industry and mobility from Madrid, with a focus on new model launches, the arrival of emerging manufacturers in Europe, and the pace of electrification across the region. He trained in automotive technology before studying journalism at Universidad Francisco de Vitoria in Madrid, and has written for the Spanish motoring outlets Motorlife Magazine and Auto10.com. He also specializes in digital and social publishing. His beat gives AutoNotion readers a view of developments that hit Europe first: Chinese brands building out dealer networks, EV mandates already in force, and model launches that reach the US years later, if at all.
Contact: info@autonocion.com