Follow us on Google Get our news on Discover Follow

A 100-foot wall around a lake on top of a Missouri mountain was overfilled by its own pumps before dawn, split open along 720 feet and let go of a billion gallons in 12 minutes, and the power plant under it now runs on a rebuilt bowl of 3 million cubic yards of concrete

A 100-foot wall around a lake on top of a Missouri mountain was overfilled by its own pumps before dawn, split open along 720 feet and let go of a billion gallons in 12 minutes, and the power plant under it now runs on a rebuilt bowl of 3 million cubic yards of concrete

{{author_name}}

Luis Reyes

Nov 19, at 2:05pm ET

There’s a little slotted hole under the faucet in your bathtub, and you’ve probably never given it a second thought. It’s an overflow drain. If you leave the water running and wander off, that hole is the reason you don’t come back to a soaked bathroom floor.

Up in the Missouri Ozarks, there’s a lake on top of a mountain that’s basically a giant bathtub. For its first 40-odd years, it didn’t have that hole. Then, one December morning a little over 20 years ago, the water kept running.

The lake is the upper reservoir of the Taum Sauk plant, which Ameren Missouri runs near Lesterville. No river feeds it, so pretty much all the water up there got there through a pump.

So how does a lake on a mountain make electricity?

It’s called pumped storage, and it’s simpler than you’d think. At night, when power is cheap, the plant pumps water uphill from a lower reservoir through a 7,000-foot tunnel. When demand spikes, it lets that water fall back down through the same machines, which now spin as turbines and feed the grid.

The plant actually uses more electricity than it makes. But it gets to move energy from the hours nobody needs it to the hours everybody does, which is why Ameren has called Taum Sauk “the biggest battery that we have,” according to the engineering database Structurae.

Today it’s a two-unit, 440-megawatt plant, per Ameren’s own Taum Sauk FAQ, and the reservoir up top holds about 1.5 billion gallons. It sits on Proffit Mountain, which you’ll occasionally see described as the highest point in Missouri. It isn’t. That title goes to Taum Sauk Mountain, about five miles away.

If the idea sounds familiar, it should. TVA runs the same trick at Raccoon Mountain in Tennessee, where a 200-ton valve sits between the mountaintop lake and the powerhouse, and an Australian project is doing it with a pair of old gold pits.

The wall went all the way around

There’s no valley to dam on a mountaintop, so the original builders made the lake by piling up a ring of rockfill about 90 feet high and capping it with a 10-foot concrete parapet wall. That ring ran roughly 6,560 feet around, a bit under a mile and a quarter of wall.

It also had no spillway. On a normal dam, a spillway is the built-in escape route that lets extra water out in a controlled way instead of over the top. Taum Sauk presumably skipped it because, with no river coming in, the only way to overfill the thing was to keep pumping after it was full. That’s a pretty bold bet when your whole defense against overfilling is a handful of sensors.

So why didn’t the pumps stop?

Rather than go off memory, I went through the report by the independent panel of consultants FERC brought in (the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission licenses and inspects dams like this one). The short answer is that three separate safeguards had problems at once.

The main level sensors were pressure transducers hanging inside pipes that ran down the inside face of the reservoir. A pressure sensor basically tells you how much water is sitting on top of it, so if it drifts upward, it thinks the lake got shallower. The pipes were only tied down at the top and bottom, and they’d shifted. The panel worked out that the sensors had moved roughly 3 feet, so the control system was reading the water about 3 feet lower than it really was.

The backup was a set of conductivity probes near the top of the wall, which trip when water touches them. But the ring had settled unevenly over the years, by as much as 1.6 feet in places on its northwest side, so the top of the parapet wasn’t level anymore. The panel counted 33 wall panels whose tops sat below the highest probe. Which means water could start spilling over the low spots before it ever reached the probe that was supposed to stop it. Then there’s the logic. A programming change made about a year earlier meant both high-level probes had to stay wet for a full 60 seconds before the pumps would shut down. Frankly, that’s more of a suggestion than a backup.

Ameren had some warning, too. According to the Association of State Dam Safety Officials’ case study, company staff found water pouring over the wall that September, and the panel’s report says the plant lowered its automatic shutoff points in October after someone noticed the pipes had moved.

Here’s how the last hour played out, using the panel’s times.

Unit 2
4:39 a.m.
Shuts itself off. The other unit keeps pumping.
Overtopping
~5:07 a.m.
Panel’s estimate of when water starts going over the wall.
BREACH
Unit 1
5:15 a.m.
Shut down manually as the wall starts to give way.
Reservoir empty
~25 min
From the first drop in level to a dry bowl.

About a billion gallons left in 12 minutes

Once the water started chewing into the outside of the rockfill, things went downhill fast. Literally. About a billion gallons left in the first 12 minutes, according to Building Design + Construction, and the full reservoir, roughly 1.4 billion gallons, was gone in about 25 minutes. The panel put the gap at about 720 feet wide at the top and 430 feet at the bottom.

A 20-foot crest of water ran down the mountain toward the Black River. It wiped out 281 acres of Johnson’s Shut-Ins State Park and ripped the park superintendent’s home off its foundation. The family survived, though not unhurt.

Nobody died, which is pretty remarkable for a flood that size. Structurae notes that the plant’s lower reservoir soaked up a lot of the water, which spared the towns downstream. I can’t give you a firm injury count, though. ASDSO’s case study says four people were hurt, while Renewable Energy World reported nine at the time.

The new bowl is solid concrete

Ameren paid a $10 million civil penalty to FERC, which Engineering News-Record described as the largest the agency had ever imposed in a hydroelectric case, and it agreed to fund another $5 million in improvements around the project. It also paid $180 million in cash and property to the state of Missouri.

Then it rebuilt the whole upper reservoir, and this time there’s no rockfill. The new ring is roller-compacted concrete. That’s basically concrete mixed so dry you can spread it with bulldozers and pack it down with vibrating rollers, layer after layer, like paving a road that just keeps getting taller.

BD+C put the job at more than 3 million cubic yards of concrete, 2.7 million of them roller-compacted, built as nine sections that are each 600 feet long and rise 100 feet above the reservoir floor. ENR reported it’s thought to be the biggest roller-compacted concrete dam in North America, and Ameren puts the rebuild at about $490 million.

The new design also gets redundant level sensors, cameras watching the water around the clock, and an overflow release structure, according to Ameren. So yes, it finally got its hole under the faucet. I’d argue that’s the least exciting thing they poured up there, and easily the most important. It’s the same thinking behind the rebuilt Edenville Dam in Michigan, which got a zigzag spillway that starts spilling on its own.

Water went back into the bowl a little over four years after the failure, and the plant was making power again that April. When I checked Ameren’s Taum Sauk page this week, it still listed the plant at 440 megawatts, with about 1.5 billion gallons sitting in that concrete ring on top of Proffit Mountain.

Credit: Missouri Department of Natural Resources

THE LOTvia The Lot

Don't bite your tongue. Speak up.

Sign in with Google when you post
ROOKIE›DRIVER›ENTHUSIAST›EXPERT›LEGEND ★
THE LOTOwner community
Visit →
Luis Reyes

Luis Reyes

With more than 14 years covering the automotive industry, Luis Reyes is a seasoned voice in the field. A law graduate, he channels his curiosity and expertise into the detailed analysis of national and international regulations that shape the automotive world. At Autonocion.com, Luis combines his strong legal background with a deep passion for vehicles — especially those that have left a mark on automotive history. His experience writing for multiple brands across the industry has established him as a trusted authority. Luis is committed to sharing his expertise and enthusiasm with enthusiasts and industry professionals alike, with a firm belief in the continuous evolution and innovation driving the auto industry forward.
Contact: info@autonocion.com
New 3D film · Watch on YouTubeWhat Happens When a Fighter Jet Runs Out of Missiles?